How to Tell if My Muscle Soreness is Normal

How to Tell if My Muscle Soreness is Normal

We've all experienced it – the post-workout muscle soreness that makes even the simplest tasks feel like a monumental challenge.

It's a reminder that we've pushed our bodies, but could it also be a sign that something needs adjusting in our workout routine? Here's the real question:

Is the soreness you're feeling during weight training a normal part of the healing process, or could it be indicating that your workout needs some fine-tuning?

Muscle soreness is a common occurrence after physical activity, but it's essential to distinguish between normal soreness and potential injury. Normal soreness typically arises within 12 to 24 hours after exercising and resolves within a few days. It often feels like a dull ache or stiffness in the muscles, and moving around may temporarily alleviate the discomfort. 

To assess whether your muscle soreness is normal, consider its onset, duration, and intensity. Normal muscle soreness occurs and gradually improves as you continue moving, whereas injury-related muscle pain often tends to worsen with activity. Additionally, if the soreness is localized to a specific area and accompanied by swelling, bruising, or sharp pain, it may indicate an injury rather than typical muscle soreness.

It's crucial to listen to your body and pay attention to any warning signs that suggest your soreness may not be normal. Let's delve into the signs that suggest your soreness might not be quite as normal as you think.

What Causes Muscle Soreness?


Muscle soreness, also known as delayed onset muscle soreness (DOMS), occurs when muscles are subjected to unfamiliar or intense physical activity. This type of delayed onset muscle soreness typically develops 12 to 24 hours after exercise and peaks within 24 to 72 hours before gradually subsiding. Several factors contribute to the development of DOMS, including microscopic damage to muscle fibers, inflammation, and the buildup of metabolic byproducts like lactic acid.

The eccentric phase of muscle contraction, which involves lengthening the muscle while under tension, is particularly responsible for triggering DOMS symptoms. Activities that emphasize eccentric muscle actions, such as downhill running or lowering weights during resistance training, often result in more pronounced soreness compared to muscles used for concentric or isometric exercises.

Furthermore, factors like an inadequate warm-up, sudden increases in exercise intensity or duration, and insufficient recovery time between workouts can exacerbate soreness. While DOMS is a natural response to physical exertion and usually resolves on its own, it's essential to implement strategies to manage soreness and prevent potential injury.

Injury vs. Soreness


When it comes to muscle soreness, distinguishing between normal sore and potential injury is crucial for preventing further harm to muscle tissue and ensuring appropriate treatment. Understanding the differences between the two can help individuals make informed decisions about their fitness routines and seek medical attention when necessary.

So, how do you know if your soreness is normal? Check off this 3-part checklist:

Intensity vs. Pain

Muscle soreness, characterized by discomfort and stiffness in the muscles following physical activity, is a natural response to exercise-induced stress. It typically occurs within 12 to 24 hours after a workout and resolves within a few days. The intensity of soreness can vary depending on factors such as the type and duration of exercise, individual fitness level, light exercise amount, and recovery strategies employed.

On the other hand, pain associated with injury is often more severe, localized, and persistent than typical soreness. It may be accompanied by swelling, bruising, or limited range of motion, indicating tissue damage but not an injury that requires medical attention.

Distinguish between the expected intensity of soreness and actual pain. Soreness is normal; acute pain is a warning.

Recovery Time

Recovery time is an essential factor in managing soreness and preventing overuse injuries. While some individuals may experience mild soreness that resolves within a day or two, others may require more extended recovery periods, especially after an intense workout or prolonged exercise sessions.

Assess how long it takes for your muscles to recover between workouts. Optimal recovery is essential for progress – it should take your muscles only a few days to recover from hard workouts, not any longer than that.


Consistency in training is key to building strength, endurance, and overall fitness levels while minimizing the risk of injury. Gradually increasing exercise intensity and duration, incorporating recovery days and recovery workouts into your routine, and practicing proper recovery strategies can help maintain consistency and optimize performance while reducing the likelihood of experiencing excessive soreness or injury.

Notice if your soreness persists beyond the usual timeframe. Consistent, prolonged soreness could indicate a need for adjustment.

Key Questions to Ask Yourself

When experiencing muscle soreness, it's essential to ask a physical therapist or yourself key questions to determine the cause and severity of the discomfort. These questions can help guide your physical decision-making process and determine whether it's safe to continue exercising or if further action is necessary.

Proper Technique

Are you maintaining proper form throughout your exercises?

Poor form and improper biomechanics can place excessive stress on muscles and joints, leading to increased soreness and the risk of injury. Reflect on your exercise technique and consider seeking guidance from a qualified fitness professional to ensure correct form and alignment during future workouts.

Overtraining Symptoms

Experiencing persistent soreness that inhibits daily activities?

Another important question to ask is whether you're experiencing symptoms of overtraining. Overtraining occurs when the affected area of the body is subjected to excessive physical stress without adequate recovery, leading to persistent muscle strain, fatigue, decreased performance, and increased susceptibility to injury. If you feel your body is sore and experiencing signs of overtraining, such as prolonged soreness, fatigue, or mood changes, it may be necessary to scale back your training intensity or incorporate more resting days into your routine.

Lack of Recovery

Noticing that your muscles aren't bouncing back as quickly as they used to?

Insufficient recovery or fueling between workouts can prolong soreness and impair exercise performance, increasing the risk of injury. Adequate rest, hydration, nutrition, and sleep are crucial for facilitating muscle repair and regeneration, replenishing energy stores, and supporting overall recovery. Incorporating active recovery activities, and recovery-focused strategies into workouts, like foam rolling, stretching, and massage during active recovery workouts can help alleviate soreness and promote optimal recovery.

Listen to Your Body

Pay attention to any sharp pains or discomfort that go beyond typical soreness.

Listening to your body's signals is essential for managing soreness and preventing injury during exercise. Pay attention to warning signs such as persistent pain, discomfort, or fatigue, and adjust your workout intensity or duration accordingly. Ignoring pain or pushing through excessive soreness can lead to further muscle damage and prolong recovery time. It's essential to strike a balance between challenging yourself and respecting your body's limits to maintain long-term health and fitness.

Periodic Assessment

Periodic assessment of your training program, performance goals, and recovery strategies is essential for optimizing fitness outcomes and preventing injury. Evaluate your progress, identify areas for improvement, and adjust your training regimen accordingly to address weaknesses, imbalances, or overuse injuries. Consulting with a qualified fitness professional or healthcare provider can provide valuable insights and guidance for designing a personalized exercise plan that promotes optimal performance and minimizes the risk of soreness and injury.

Is It Bad to Work Out When You're Sore?

Many people wonder whether it's a good idea, or safe to exercise when experiencing soreness. While exercising with mild to moderate soreness is generally safe and may even help alleviate discomfort by increasing blood flow and promoting muscle recovery, it's essential to listen to your body and adjust your post-workout routine accordingly.

Exercising with mild soreness can help improve circulation and facilitate muscle repair and regeneration. However, if the sore is severe, sharp, or localized to the aching muscles or specific area, it may indicate an underlying injury that requires rest and proper treatment. It's crucial to differentiate between normal soreness and pain that indicates potential injury to avoid further damage and promote optimal recovery.

When It's Safe to "Push Through the Pain" and When It Isn't


Pushing through mild soreness during exercise is generally safe and may even be beneficial for promoting recovery and adaptation. However, it's essential to differentiate between normal soreness and pain that indicates potential injury.

If the soreness is mild to moderate and improves with movement, it's usually safe to continue exercising at a reduced intensity or focus on different muscle groups. However, if the sore is severe, sharp, localized to a specific area, or limited range of motion, it may indicate tissue damage that requires rest and proper treatment.

How to Treat and Prevent Soreness


Treating and preventing soreness involves implementing various strategies to manage inflammation, facilitate muscle recovery, reduce swelling, and optimize your overall health and wellness. Incorporating proper warm-up and cool-down routines, staying hydrated, consuming a balanced diet rich in nutrients, and getting adequate rest are essential for minimizing soreness and promoting recovery.

Proper warm-up and cool-down routines can help prepare your body for exercise to facilitate recovery and relieve sore muscles afterward. A dynamic warm-up that includes light cardio, dynamic stretches, and mobility exercises helps increase blood flow to the muscles and improve joint flexibility, reducing the risk of injury and less sore muscles during exercise. Similarly, a cool-down routine that includes static stretches and foam rolling helps alleviate muscle tension and promote relaxation, facilitating recovery and reducing post-exercise soreness.

Staying hydrated and consuming a balanced diet rich in nutrients is essential for supporting muscle repair and recovery. Adequate hydration helps flush out metabolic byproducts and toxins from the muscles, reducing inflammation. Consuming a balanced diet that includes lean protein, complex carbohydrates, healthy fats, vitamins, and minerals provides essential nutrients for muscle repair and regeneration. Additionally, incorporating anti-inflammatory foods like fruits, vegetables, and omega-3 fatty acids can help reduce inflammation and alleviate soreness.

Diet and Supplements

Nutrition plays a crucial role in managing soreness and supporting overall recovery and performance. Consuming a balanced diet that includes adequate protein, carbohydrates, healthy fats, vitamins, and minerals can provide essential nutrients for muscle repair and regeneration. Additionally, certain supplements like omega-3 fatty acids, antioxidants, and branched-chain amino acids may help reduce inflammation, and support recovery when incorporated into a well-rounded nutrition plan. However, it's essential to consult with a healthcare professional before starting any new supplement regimen to ensure safety and efficacy.

Understanding the nature of the sore and how to differentiate between a normal sore and a potential injury is essential for maintaining a safe and effective exercise routine. By asking key questions, listening to your body, and implementing proper recovery strategies, you can manage soreness effectively and minimize the risk of injury. Remember to prioritize proper technique, rest, hydration, nutrition, and periodic assessment of your training program to support optimal recovery and long-term fitness success. By taking a proactive approach, you can continue to enjoy the benefits of regular exercise while minimizing discomfort and reducing the risk of injury.

Achieving your fitness goals isn't just about a hard workout pushing through the pain. It's about understanding your own lower body and upper body and part's signals and adjusting your workout routine accordingly.

Get your 7-day free trial of all our workout programs today.